Uncovering the Hidden Gems: 5 Must-Try Secret Menu Drinks at Dutch Bros. Coffee!

This post may contain affiliate links and we may earn a commission, but it won’t affect our product choices.

Table of Contents

If you’re anything like me, your day simply isn’t complete without a cup of delicious, bold-flavored coffee. Perhaps that’s why, several years ago, on a trip across the Pacific Northwest, I found myself becoming a Dutch Bros Coffee enthusiast. It was more than just the inviting aroma of coffee that drew me in; it was the vibrant atmosphere and the anticipation of something unique, something not easily found elsewhere. And that’s when I stumbled across Dutch Bros’ secret menu.

Now, don’t get me wrong, everything on their regular menu is fantastic. But there’s something particularly thrilling about whispering, “I’ll have the Ninja Turtle, please,” to a barista and receiving a nod of approval in return. So without further ado, let’s explore the treasures of the Dutch Bros. secret menu together!

best dutch bro coffee
Uncovering the Hidden Gems 5 Must Try Secret Menu Drinks at Dutch Bros. Coffee

Why the Secret Menu?

In today’s age of personalization, the ‘one-size-fits-all’ model just doesn’t cut it. The thrill of ordering off-menu, especially at a popular place like Dutch Bros, is simply exhilarating. I am pretty sure the whole concept of secret menus was started by some caffeinated mavericks wanting to experiment with flavors, creating their own customized drinks. In turn, these delicious concoctions have become popular through word of mouth.

The secret menu is the epitome of personalization and customer experience. It’s like stumbling upon an exclusive club within a club. Each cup somehow feels more special; each flavor seems more intricate and enduring. They are the hidden gems of the best Dutch Bros Coffee that make your routine coffee run all the more exciting!

Dutch Bros. Secret Menu Drinks

Having worked in the vibrant world of cafes, particularly the Boat Basin Cafe in downtown New York, I find immense joy in trying unconventional coffee recipes. And let me tell you, none have fascinated me as much as these five secret masterpieces of Dutch Bros. Be prepared to embark on an incredible flavor journey!

1. White Coffee Cookie:

Uncovering the Hidden Gems: 5 Must-Try Secret Menu Drinks at Dutch Bros. Coffee! 1
26756334 10154881202672030 2202661934595613604 o

Imagine biting into a freshly baked white chocolate macadamia nut cookie, the sweet and slightly nutty flavors gradually spreading over your palate. Now, imagine that sensation in a cup of coffee. That’s Dutch Bros’ White Coffee Cookie for you! This delectable drink utilizes their distinctive white coffee beans and melds them with the flavors of white chocolate and macadamia nut. Trust me, once you go white, you’ll reconsider what you know about coffee!

2. Ninja Turtle:

Uncovering the Hidden Gems: 5 Must-Try Secret Menu Drinks at Dutch Bros. Coffee! 2
42b527ab4ae8207e1904b149876adc7c dutch bros ninja turtles

Now, while the name might pique the interest of any Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles fan, rest assured, there are no green cartoon characters in this drink (though that would be fun!). Instead, the Ninja Turtle is a blissful blend of white chocolate and classic mint, offering you a sweet and refreshing taste. It’s an unexpected duo that creates a harmonious symphony of flavors, reminding me of mint-chocolate chip ice cream on a hot summer day. Pro tip: Pair it with Dutch Bros’ amazing muffins for a perfect mid-afternoon snack.

3. Cookie:

Uncovering the Hidden Gems: 5 Must-Try Secret Menu Drinks at Dutch Bros. Coffee! 3

If you’re still hooked on the ‘cookie’ theme like me, then let’s expand a little. Unlike the nutty ‘White Coffee Cookie,’ this one simply goes by ‘Cookie.’ Why? Because it nails that classic chocolate-chip cookie flavor without any distractions. The drink combines chocolate macadamia nut flavor with a hint of coconut. And boy, is it a delight! Rich and velvety, each sip is a nostalgic invitation to childhood.

4. Gummy Bear:

Uncovering the Hidden Gems: 5 Must-Try Secret Menu Drinks at Dutch Bros. Coffee! 4
12778706 10153507100779779 7276772117332897448 o.jpg?stp=cp0 dst jpg e15 p320x320 q65& nc cat=105&ccb=1 7& nc sid=2d5d41& nc ohc=4kOkAJGSk 4AX vd3VH& nc ht=scontent akl1 1

Never in my wildest dreams would I have imagined a ‘Gummy Bear’ flavored coffee. But that’s the fun of Dutch Bros’ secret menu! The title had me baffled and intrigued, and the taste did not disappoint. Sour and refreshing aren’t two attributes I’d usually seek in a coffee, but the Dutch Bros’ Gummy Bear made me think twice. It’s fruity, vibrant, and surprisingly well-paired with the boldness of coffee. Pair this with a day of binge-watching your favorite series, (Dutch Bros vs. Starbucks themed shows, perhaps?) and you’re in for a treat!

5. Dirty Caterpillar:

Uncovering the Hidden Gems: 5 Must-Try Secret Menu Drinks at Dutch Bros. Coffee! 5
29511148 10156110401143632 1782941005897531392 n.jpg? nc cat=103&ccb=1 7& nc sid=2c4854& nc ohc=jtNqemrMuVoAX qnMJG& nc ht=scontent akl1 1

While the name may sound strange, the taste, my friends, is anything but. The Dirty Caterpillar is a combination of creme de menthe and white chocolate sauce, which when paired with a drizzle of dark chocolate sauce and the robust coffee flavor creates a contrasting and tantalizing mix. Can you taste the decadence seeping through already?

From indulging in the sweetness of cookies to the refreshing twist of gummy bears, navigating the Dutch Bros. secret menu has been a whirlwind adventure! But, we’re only halfway there. Let’s explore further in the Dutch Bros. universe as we uncover how to order these delicious secret beverages, the tailor-made healthier options, and the unique experiences of loyal customers who have also discovered these hidden treasures.

How to Order Secret Menu Drinks

Ordering a secret menu drink can seem a bit tricky, especially if it’s your first time. But fear not, it’s as easy as pie, or coffee, in this case! Just walk up to the counter or pull up in the drive-thru, ask for your drink by name (White Coffee Cookie, Ninja Turtle, Cookie, Gummy Bear, or Dirty Caterpillar), and watch the smile spread on the barista’s face.

Should you want to experiment, customize your drink to your heart’s content. Dutch Bros. encourages creativity in their relentless pursuit of customer satisfaction. So, go ahead and ask for your Ninja Turtle to be a bit less sweet or your Gummy Bear to have an extra shot of espresso. They might even let you toss in some vegan options or sugar-free syrups from their extensive menu. Make your secret drink truly your own!

Customer Favorites

Every repeat order is a testament to Dutch Bros’ commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. And what better way to authenticate these secret menu items than by sharing customer experiences? As someone who enjoys delving deep into online reviews and social commentary about favorite delicacies, I found a wealth of praise for these secret drink recipes.

“The Ninja Turtle has got to be my all-time favorite! Perfect balance of minty freshness and creamy sweetness!'” shared a delighted customer on Dutch Bros’ Instagram page. Another lover of the Cookie revealed, “It’s like sipping on my favorite childhood memory.

These are sneak peeks into the love Dutch Bros. receives daily. So, pop into your nearest Dutch Bros. Coffee outlet and join the conversation.

Healthier Options and Customizations

Dutch Bros’ secret menu is not just a decadent indulgence. For the health-conscious coffee lovers, it offers healthier choices too. If you love the White Coffee Cookie but are watching your calories, skim milk or almond milk can replace whole milk. If the Cookie’s sugar level is high, a sugar-free version will delight you just as much, without the guilt.

You can also experiment with the Dutch Bros. coffee beans to make your own Dutch Bros Coffee at home. All it takes is a little creativity and a love for coffee.

😀You may also like: Top 10 Health-Friendly, Low-Calorie Dutch Bros Drinks


The Dutch Bros’ secret menu is not just a menu. It is a delightful journey into the world of bold flavors and creative combinations, where every sip elicits joy. Undoubtedly, these five hidden gems are worth trying. Not only for the intriguing names and flavors, but for the sheer thrill of being ‘in the know’ – for being part of the Dutch Bros. secret society.

So, go ahead, try these refreshing and unique coffee drinks. Twist them, turn them, experiment with them. Fill your Dutch Bros reusable cup with deliciousness and don’t forget to tell us about your favorite secret drink!

One thing’s for certain – once you delve into the secret world of Dutch Bros., coffee will never be the same again.

Ready for a Coffee Adventure? Try Dutch Bros. Secret Menu Today!

Are you intrigued yet? Are you ready to order a Gummy Bear the next time you’re at Dutch Bros. Coffee? Or perhaps the Dirty Caterpillar has got you curious? Walk into your nearest Dutch Bros. or whip it up at home. Go, treat yourself to these secret delights.

Don’t forget to share your Dutch Bros Coffee reviews with us and the community. Whether you’ve tried the White Coffee Cookie or the delectable Cookie, let us know how enthusiastic you are about these secret menu favorites!


Relevant Reads

Table of Contents