Is Your Mayo Safe? Don’t Risk It! 5 Ways to Tell if Mayo is Bad

This post may contain affiliate links and we may earn a commission, but it won’t affect our product choices.

Table of Contents

Hey there, food lovers! John Bird here, your friendly neighborhood chef and coffee connoisseur. I’ve seen my fair share of spoiled ingredients in my years at the Boat Basin Cafe in downtown New York.

Today, I want to talk about a kitchen staple that can turn into a kitchen nightmare if you’re not careful: mayonnaise.

Accidentally left your mayo out? Worried that unopened jar is past its prime?

Here’s how to quickly spot spoiled mayo and avoid food poisoning:

Summary of Key Points
🚨 Changed Color? (Yellow/Brown) – Toss it!
🤢 Smells Sour or Odd? – Don’t risk it.
🌊 Liquid Separating? – Not safe anymore.
👎 Tastes Off? – Spit it out, better safe than sorry.
🍄 Mold? – Absolutely unsafe.
Is Your Mayo Safe? Don't Risk It! 5 Ways to Tell if Mayo is Bad 1
How to Tell If Mayo is Bad How to Store It Right 1

How to Tell If Mayo Has Gone Bad

  1. Weird texture? Ditch it! Mayo should be smooth and creamy. If you see lumps, separation, or weird liquid on top, it’s past its prime. Think of it like this: How do you know if milk has gone bad? Similar principle here!
  2. Does your mayo look yellow or brown? Fresh mayo has an off-white color. If it’s taken on yellowish or brownish colors, it’s time to toss it. (This is a great place to use a long-tail keyword like “is mayo supposed to be yellow?”)
  3. Funky smell? Trust your nose! Good mayo has a mild aroma. If it smells sour, acidic, or just plain off, throw it away. A helpful long-tail keyword here could be “why does my mayo smell weird?”
  4. The cautious taste test: If you’re still unsure, a tiny taste won’t hurt. If it tastes bitter, sour, or off, spit it out and don’t risk food poisoning.
  5. Mold is a major no-no! If you see ANY sign of mold, throw the entire jar away immediately.

Remember, when it comes to food safety, always trust your instincts. If something seems off about your mayo, it’s better to play it safe and start with a fresh jar.

💁🏻‍♂️ You may want to try: Mayo In Coffee

What Happens If You Eat Bad Mayo?

Eating spoiled mayonnaise puts you at a high risk for food poisoning. Bacteria like Salmonella, Listeria, and E. coli can grow in old mayo and make you seriously ill. Symptoms can include:

  • Nausea and vomiting
  • Abdominal pain and cramps
  • Diarrhea (sometimes bloody)
  • Fever and chills

In severe cases, food poisoning can even land you in the hospital. Don’t take the risk – always check your mayo before using it!

Store Mayo Like a Pro

how long does mayo last
how long does mayo last

Want to keep your mayo fresh as long as possible? Here’s how:

✅ DO refrigerate mayo immediately after use.

❌ DON’T leave mayo at room temp for over 2 hours (1 hour if it’s hot out).

✅ DO keep opened mayo in the fridge, not the pantry.

❌ DON’T freeze mayo to make it last longer (it ruins the texture).

✅ DO use clean utensils to prevent cross-contamination.

Mayo Shelf Life: What to Expect

So, how long does mayo actually last? It depends on the type and whether it’s been opened. Check out this handy chart:

TypeUnopened Shelf LifeOpened Shelf Life
Regular (Store-Bought)3-4 months2 months
Homemade1 week3-4 days
Vegan2-3 months1 month

Of course, these are just guidelines. Always go by the “best by” date on the jar and your own senses. If something seems off, it’s better to be safe than sorry.

Mayo Mythbusters

There’s a lot of misinformation out there about mayo. Let’s set the record straight:

Homemade mayo lasts longer than store-bought.Commercial mayo has preservatives that make it last longer.
Mayo will make you gain weight.Mayo in moderation can be part of a balanced diet.
Store-bought mayo is full of harmful chemicals.Many brands now offer natural, organic options.
You can’t use olive oil to make mayo at home.You can, but it has a strong flavor. Light olive oil works best.
Adding extra lemon juice/vinegar will make mayo last longer.It helps, but even acidic mayo can spoil over time.


My mayo expired a week ago. Is it still okay to use?

If it’s been refrigerated and looks/smells/tastes normal, it’s probably safe for a week or two after expiration. But use caution and check for signs of spoilage.

Can I freeze mayonnaise to extend its shelf life?

Technically yes, but I don’t recommend it. Mayo tends to separate when frozen, ruining the texture. It’s safer to just buy a new jar.

How Long Does Mayonnaise Last After Opening?

Once you open a jar of mayo, it will last you up to 2 months. Before it’s opened, a jar of mayo can last in the refrigerator for about three months or until it expires. 

I accidentally left my mayo out overnight. Can I still use it?

It depends how warm your kitchen was. The USDA says if mayo is kept above 50°F for more than 8 hours, it should be discarded. Personally, I’d toss it to be safe.

The Bottom Line

Mayonnaise is a tasty addition to many dishes, but like all foods, it can spoil over time. Knowing how to spot bad mayo is an important skill for any home cook or sandwich lover.

Remember, if the color, smell, taste, or texture seems off, don’t chance it. It’s just not worth the risk of food poisoning. Follow proper storage guidelines and always check your mayo before using it.

And there you have it – everything you need to know to keep your mayo game strong! Have you ever had a run-in with spoiled mayo? Share your stories (and favorite mayo recipes) in the comments below!

Until next time, this is John Bird reminding you to stay safe, eat well, and always trust your gut (especially when it comes to questionable condiments).

Relevant Reads

Table of Contents