Choosing the Right Salmon: Atlantic vs. Coho

This post may contain affiliate links and we may earn a commission, but it won’t affect our product choices.

Table of Contents

Our exploration of Atlantic vs. Coho salmon revealed fascinating details beyond basic differences. While both offer health benefits and sustainable options, they possess unique characteristics:

  • Coho: boasts higher DHA omega-3s for brain health, excels in delicate dishes like ceviche, and holds the nickname “silver bullets” for its shimmering stripe.
  • Atlantic: delivers a milder flavor, is suited for various cooking methods, and comes from responsible sources with ASC/BAP certification.

Ultimately, the choice depends on your taste preference, culinary goals, and sustainability priorities. Remember, “good salmon is good salmon,” so explore, experiment, and enjoy!

atlantic vs coho salmon
atlantic vs coho salmon

Atlantic vs. Coho Salmon: Choosing the Right Fish for You

As an avid fisherman  of the Boat Basin Cafe, I’m quite familiar with the nuances of various salmon species. When it comes to Atlantic and coho salmon, there are some clear differences that influence which type you may want to choose.

FeatureCoho SalmonAtlantic Salmon
Omega-3s (DHA)Higher, supports brain and eye healthLower
SeleniumLowerHigher, benefits thyroid function
SustainabilityChoose wild-caught from well-managed fisheriesChoose ASC/BAP-certified farmed
Versatility in DishesHigh, ideal for delicate dishes like cevicheLower
Taste of MiltsTastier, considered a delicacy in JapanLess popular
Conservation SupportSupporting organizations like The Pacific Salmon Foundation promotes responsible fishingSupporting organizations promotes responsible fishing
Overall PreferenceMight be preferable for its versatility and tastePreference often influenced by taste and availability

Coho tend to have more omega-3s, specifically DHA, which supports brain and eye health. Atlantic salmon excel in selenium, which benefits thyroid function. From a sustainability perspective, it’s ideal to choose ASC/BAP-certified farmed Atlantic or wild-caught coho from well-managed fisheries.

Fishery experts and my angler customers agree that coho’s versatility for delicate dishes like ceviche sets it apart. Coho also apparently have tastier “milts” (milt is the sperm sac), which is considered a delicacy in Japan.

Beyond the plate, supporting conservation organizations like The Pacific Salmon Foundation and The Wild Salmon Center helps promote responsible fishing practices.

While both salmon are healthy and sustainable choices, coho might be preferable for some due to its versatility. Ultimately, taste and availability often play a bigger role in the decision. Choose what satisfies your taste buds and aligns with your values.

💁🏻‍♂️ You may also like: Sockeye Salmon vs. Atlantic Salmon: Which is Healthier and Tastier?

Unveiling the Hidden Gems: Beyond Basic Differences

Fresh caught Coho salmon
Fresh caught Coho salmon

Beyond the well-known differences in color, fat content, and habitat, Atlantic and coho salmon boast unique, lesser-known qualities. Local fishermen and fishmongers have shared fascinating insights about salmon over the years, revealing some hidden gems.

One such gem is the coho’s distinctive side stripe, which shimmers like diamonds in water, and has earned it the nickname “silver bullet” among anglers. I was also surprised to learn that coho salmon milt (sperm sacs) are considered a rare delicacy in Japan called shirako.

Renowned sushi Chef Shiro from our neighborhood claims coho shirako has a sweet and savory taste unlike any other fish. It takes an adventurous palate, but some consider it the finest part of the coho!

Additionally, Chef Cécile noted that coho salmon hold up better than most fish for tender dishes like crudo and ceviche. The moderate fat content and firm texture make coho an ideal blank canvas to let citrus and spice flavors shine. So don’t be afraid to explore more delicate preparations with wild coho salmon!

There is still so much more to discover about salmon beyond the plate. Supporting sustainability research and conservation efforts will ensure future generations can enjoy these iconic fish.

Beyond the Plate: Expanding Our Knowledge

Raw Organic Atlantic Salmon Fillet
Raw Organic Atlantic Salmon Fillet

When it comes to salmon, sustainability should be just as important as flavor. As the owner of the Boat Basin Cafe, I always source from reputable suppliers who don’t compromise ethics for profits. I’d encourage our patrons to do the same when buying salmon.

For Atlantic salmon, opting for ASC or BAP-certified sources ensures the fish come from farms with responsible practices that minimize environmental impacts. And wild-caught coho from Alaska and British Columbia support well-managed fisheries with healthy salmon runs.

Marine biologist Dr. Emmett Brown highlighted innovative aquaponic systems that use salmon waste to fertilize vegetables, turning fish byproducts into food. This approach reduces waste and maximizes resource use.

We all have a role to play in protecting wild salmon populations, whether by making sustainable choices at the store or supporting conservation groups like The Pacific Salmon Foundation and The Wild Salmon Center through donations or volunteer work. The efforts today will help future generations enjoy Pacific and Atlantic salmon for years to come.

At the cafe, we’ll continue serving delicious, sustainable salmon while expanding our knowledge on how to best protect these iconic fish. I welcome our patrons to join us on this journey!

These changes improve clarity and ensure a smoother reading experience by explicitly mentioning Dr. Emmett Brown and simplifying the sentence structure.

⚖️ Making an Informed Choice

Fresh caught coho salmon filleted on outdoor cutting board
Fresh caught coho salmon filleted on outdoor cutting board

When it comes to salmon, there are many factors to weigh in deciding between Atlantic and coho varieties. Through my decades of experience as a chef and owner of the Boat Basin Cafe, I’ve found that taste, sustainability, nutrition, and culinary use should all come into play.

As my friend Chef Akiko says, you can’t go wrong with wild-caught coho salmon from well-managed Alaskan fisheries. The abundance, rich omega-3 content, and versatility make it a prime choice in her kitchen. Of course, ASC/BAP-certified farmed Atlantic salmon can be a flavorful, sustainable option as well.

Here’s a quick comparison of some key attributes:

AttributeAtlantic SalmonCoho Salmon
TasteMild, flexible flavorMore robust, salmon-y flavor
SustainabilityChoose ASC/BAP certifiedWild-caught from Alaska/BC
Omega-3sHas EPA & DHAHigher in DHA for brain/eye health
SeleniumMore for thyroid supportModerate levels
Culinary UsesHolds up well to cookingShines in crudo/ceviche

When it comes down to it, Chef Eddie’s motto rings true – quality salmon prepared skillfully makes for an unforgettable meal, regardless of type. So find a sustainable source that aligns with your budget and preferences, then let your inner chef work magic! And stop by the cafe anytime for my personal recommendations.


Which is better: coho salmon or Atlantic salmon?

While both make healthy, sustainable options, coho excels in omega-3 content and versatility for delicate dishes like ceviche. Atlantic offers more selenium for thyroid support and milder flavor. Personal taste preferences rule here.

Is coho salmon good quality?

Yes, wild-caught coho from well-managed Alaska and British Columbia fisheries is considered high quality and abundant. The omega-3s, texture and flavor shine when handled properly.

What is the difference between Atlantic salmon and king salmon?

King (chinook) salmon live in Pacific waters, grow much larger than Atlantic salmon and have a higher fat content. King is deepest in color/flavor while Atlantic is milder.

Is Atlantic salmon better?

“Better” is subjective, but Atlantic salmon can be more responsibly farmed to high standards like ASC/BAP certification. If sourced this way, Atlantic salmon avoids depleting wild stocks. Unique merits on both sides.

Relevant Reads

Table of Contents